Saturday, 8 March 2014

The Middle Class

We have heard, lately, that there is assault on the middle class.  The disparity that exists between the 1% and the 99%.  Tax the rich.  Redistribute income. Having lived these 78 years, I have heard this before. 

I grew up in a country that created an extraordinary social safety net back in 1936.  Social reforms that were not duplicated in other countries (except in some Scandinavian countries) for many years thereafter.  We had publically funded major medical insurance in the late ‘60s and universal first dollar medical insurance by the mid seventies.  Canada has good primary and secondary education and (by comparison to the US) cheap college education.  We have a redistribution program from “have” provinces to “have not” provinces. We are taxed, personally, a little higher than our neighbour to the south but, in my view, we get excellent value for tax dollar spent. 

So what happened?  Why do we have folks camped outside our business centers and stock exchanges chanting slogans?  One of the reasons (among many others) is a rising level of expectations. 

Life has gotten ‘way more complicated.  When my parents were married home ownership was not easy.  Most people scraped by and savings were hard to accumulate.  However, education was the hallmark of our family ethos.  It was my job to become educated and to lead a life that exceeded, financially and socially, that of my parents.  I was expected to pay for my higher education.  True that I graduated high school (when high school graduates were still able to get a decent job), college and grad school at a time when jobs were plentiful and salaries and wages allowed the worker to live a decent “middle class” life.  Our parent’s and my expectations were, in comparison to today’s workers, reasonably low.  Graduate, get married, buy a house and get “established”--all on a one-income family.  Vacations were summer affairs and the extravagance of summer camps for children were reasonably affordable. 

While there are many reasons why jobs are less available now than when I was college age including globalization, the wholesale reduction of manufacturing jobs, the gutting of the labour unions, etc., there has been a wholesale increase in the level of expectations of the average family. 

Housing.  We were content to have, for our first house purchase, a (by today’s standards) tiny house in a bland subdivision of tract housing.  We paid $17,000 that, in today’s dollars would be about $170,000.  We did it in order to “get into the market” and allow inflation to work for us.  We moved to a larger house (reasonable by today’s standards) that cost, land included, about $35,000 or about $350,000 in today’s dollars.  When I examine today’s housing market (aside from those who move into established neighbourhoods) I see starter houses that well exceed both in space and accouterments, what our second house had.  In many cases this has resulting in couples being “house poor” in that they can barely afford the house and cannot afford to furnish it.  A significant factor is that land prices has skyrocketed and services that were once built into the property tax system are now paid up front.  I am only making the point that the current ethos is to buy a first house that is much more ambitious house than what we owned.  Rising expectations. 

Food and Family.  In real terms food is cheaper today than it was when we were a young family.  Winter meant root vegetables and probably no more exotic fruit than oranges.  With cheap sea transport we started importing exotic fruits and vegetables during the winter months.  There were not 30 brands of morning cereals and adding sugar to Rice Krispys was unknown.  Kids played outside and ran off whatever calories they took on.  Junk food was limited to potato chips and ice cream.  Now dense calorie foods are debilitating a generation of kids who, when combined with a more sedentary life, become over weight or obese.  That said, rising levels of expectations ensnare us.  We have become convinced that mass produced foods are bad for us and pay astounding premiums for food that is “naturally” grown.  We pay exorbitant prices for store bought coffee and coffee that comes in little cups that cost about 50 cents each.  It is not unusual to spend $4 per day on specialty coffees and much more on snacks.  Eating or cooking at home has become too difficult.  What with take out pizzas or “assembled” meals (the supermarket has figured out that there is about a 15% margin for whole lettuce and a $65% margin for cut up and bagged lettuce) a larger part of our budgets are now consumed on eating food out or taking in.  Family expenses now include expensive pastimes for kids such as hockey and dance (which is now a competitive event) not to mention expensive electronic toys such as mobile telephones, iPads, and large HD TVs.  Since wages are relatively finite these expensive toys are financed, largely, by credit card purchases.  Hence, an unduly large amount of family income is spent on debt service.

Cars and Trucks.  The basic car has now been enhanced by so much electronic equipment (both operational and entertaining) that I suspect that the value of the actual vehicle has not exceeded inflation when a car cost about $1,700 to buy in 1956.  However, what people are willing to pay for (and seem to have the money for) is a collection of gadgets and playthings that would have defied the imagination of my parents and myself in the 1960s.  We now pay for off road vehicles that are for entertainment only.  We have figured out how to pay for these things through innovative financing such as leasing and 0 interest loans.  This consumes an inordinate portion of family income.


These are but a few instances of the impact that rising expectations have on the cost of living.  But when our middle class says that life has become unaffordable they should have a hard look on expenditures and what value for money these expenditures represent.  They might not be as badly off as they think. 

Saturday, 8 February 2014

Foreign Trading Corporations for Canadian Corporations

If a Canadian corporation does a significant amount of business ex-Canada it may benefit from the formation of a foreign trading corporation incorporated in a low/no tax jurisdiction. 

Assuming that the Canadian corporation’s net income is taxed at about 25% it is possible to structure both Canadian and offshore corporations so that the tax load on foreign sourced net income falls to 2.5% or lower.  An added benefit to this kind of structure is that offshore net after tax profits, if earned in a country that has a tax treaty (and not in some jurisdictions a tax information agreement) with Canada, can be repatriated to Canada tax free in the form of inter corporate dividends.

We will examine three kinds of examples. 

The first example is that of a Canadian company that manufactures products in Canada and sells  significant amounts of product ex-Canada.  These ex-Canada sales can be to the United States[1].  Under these circumstances the Canadian corporation can establish an offshore world-wide distributor in a no/low tax jurisdiction.  We prefer to use Barbados where the tax rate of net income does not exceed 2.5%.  In this example the Canadian company would sell its products to the Barbados company at such a price so that a significant portion of the profit would be earned in Barbados.  The inter-corporate pricing is called “transfer pricing” and would require a study to insure that the pricing is fair between the companies. 

The second example is a Canadian company that produces nothing in Canada but owns intellectual property such as patents or copyrights that it sells to an offshore trading company to be resold to others ex-Canada.  The price at which the intellectual property is sold to the offshore trading company should be supported by a third party valuation.

The third example is a Canadian company that purchases products produced by an independent third party either in Canada or elsewhere and resells it ex-Canada.  In such a case transfer pricing is not required and all of the profit can be accumulated in the offshore trading company.

For any of these programs to be effective the “management mind and control” of the offshore trading corporation must reside offshore.  Whiel the foreign trading corporation could be a wholly owned subsidiary of the Canadian company there must be sufficient operational and decision-making control offshore so that the separate legal existence of the offshore company can be justified.  What kind of control that constitutes depends on the facts of each case.  However, suffice to say, this is significant issue that cannot be downplayed.
The formation of an offshore trading corporation goes well beyond the creation of the offshore corporation.  Each transaction must be designed so that the business relationship between parent and subsidiary is set out by agreement (or agreements) and substantiated by the practice between them.  No matter how well intentioned, if the parties disregard their business arrangement then the program will fail.  Matters of who pays what bills, who fields telephone calls, what address is printed in invoices, what is disclosed on websites are just a few that must be dealt with by advisors and professionals.  Matters relating to what entity should receive dividends from the offshore corporation also form part of the plan. 

Lastly, mention should be made of a strategy for asset protection.  While this is true of any business venture, it is particularly true for a business structure that may be open to capricious and arbitrary behavior by taxing authorities.  This kind of planning may be difficult to businesses where profits are reinvested in hard assets or accounts receivable or inventory.  But where the business produces mainly cash the question of asset protection should be paramount in planning the venture.

The right kind of advisor.  Of course we are prejudiced and think that we give our clients superior advice and service.  But ask our clients.  Before we advise on an offshore trading plan we spend many unpaid hours in determining if such a plan would be beneficial to our potential client.  If a plan is recommended, we work as a team to put the plan in place.  First there are schematics.  Then there are consultations with our offshore legal and management providers.  Drafting notes are prepared for our legal team so that precious (and expensive) professional time is not wasted.  Documents implementing the plan are drafted and reviewed by our team.  Accountants on our team will advise on Canadian tax aspects of the plan including splitting income and capital gains exemptions through the use of trust and holding companies.  We stay wit the transaction until it is operating smoothly.  We operate on a pre-negotiated fee structure and create a budget for the implementation of the plan.




[1] Note that this example does not apply where a Canadian company has sufficient presence in the US or other foreign country so as to render that presence a “permanent establishment” under the Canada – US tax treaty.

Thursday, 6 February 2014

FATCA is a little less fat.

The recent signing of a Canada-US agreement on how FATCA is to be enforced in Canada is a half a loaf at best.  The Canadian Banker's Association (CBA) has stated that the agreement is an improvement of what was to be an intolerable situation but only an improvement.  "Canada is not a tax haven for US citizens", it said.  (Consider the US citizen that wins a Canadian lottery--taxable in the US and not taxable in Canada.  I am certain that the funds would be safely invested in Canada--but that's another story).

So, information on bank accounts (with the now exception of many tax free accounts such as RRSPs and TFSAs) owned by US citizens or those who were born in the US will be collected (at a huge cost) and sent to our friendly CRA where the information will be shared with the IRS.  An improvement?  This changes the role of the CRA from tax collector to inquisitor or agent of the IRS.  Still, in my view, an attack on our sovereignty.

What the Finance Minister should have said was that the IRS should take a hike with respect to Canadian enforcement.  But how could it do so in the face of impending approval/non approval of the Keystone pipeline.  Not a change.  Uncle Sam says "jump" and Canada says "how high".

Friday, 31 January 2014

Privacy and What It Means to You

Just consider what the current means of surveillance would have meant in the hands of Joe McCarthy.  Then it was just people snooping on people.  I suppose the occasional envelope was steamed open and mail was intercepted.  Investigative techniques are not to be used by either the Canadian or US investigators on domestic citizens.  Oh yeah! We now have privacy commissioners and others who are mandated to insure our privacy but little is really done about the domestic snooping that appears to be going on constantly.  How are we to respond?

On a level of personal security we all know that we are to use complex passwords that can't be easily hacked.  However,  a determined hacker will inevitably breach our firewalls and well- meant complex passwords.  Given that most banking transactions are now done over the Internet or some kind of safe network we can only hope that banks and other financial institutions are doing their stuff.  My inside information is that banks are bleeding like the rest of us.  However, banks and other financial institutions do pay up when your account is raided.  This adds to the cost of banking but I am not sure how much it impacts the average consumer.  And then there are credit cards and debit cards (another aspect of the banking business).  The US refused to accept the chip technology (on the grounds that it was too expensive) that we take for granted in Canada and they are now paying the price. We a just a bit more secure with out chip technology but only a bit.  And then there is Facebook and Twitter where we place our lives on display for the public to see (latest dumb post: going to bed now...").

There is a tort doctrine in common law called "contributory negligence".  This doctrine applies where one of the parties, usually the plaintiff, has done something that contributes to his harm.  Riding over the centre of the road, attending a hockey game where he is likely to be hit by a puck are just two examples.  When we place ourselves in harm's way we cannot squeal too loudly when harm occurs.  I believe that this principle applies to privacy.  We have consented to put our lives out in public and we can hardly complain when those who are malevolent take advantage of our exposure.  If you leave your wallet on the street can you complain when someone takes it?  Even the common law states that a "finder" has good title against everyone except the rightful owners.  Don't do dumb things.

We have allowed all of this to happen to ourselves and when bad things happen we can hardly complain.  If we are to be catalogued and carded for the delivery of health care can we really, really, expect that some day some bureaucrat will have that information on his/her laptop and then leave that very laptop in the mall.  Life happens.  Is there really a firewall that can't be breached?  By anyone?  When we set up state-of-the-art spying agencies can we really, really expect that they won't spy? On us? As they say on Monday Night Football, "C'mon man!".

I am all for Snowdon and everyone else who is a whistleblower on spying (with the exception of exposing agents whose lives might be in danger).  This is because people like Snowdon turn the tables on those who would keep spying on us a secret.  If "they" can spy on us why can't we spy on "them"?  Therefore, if we are contemplating criminal behaviour why can't one of the deterrents be the fear that we are being spied on and that our criminal behaviour will be found out.   A bit Big Brother? It's already here.  So we must all comport ourselves in a manner that assumes that we are being spied upon.  If we don't like it we have to turn the clock back 40 years and no one wants to do that.


Thursday, 30 January 2014

Where You Live--The Conrad Black Tax Case

An article today in the Financial Post by Vern Krishna (a venerable tax lawyer, professor and writer) points out how arbitrary the courts can be in dealing with tax issues.  As pointed out by Prof. Krishna tax treaties are negotiated and enacted so that a person or corporation is not taxed twice on the same income by the treaty partners.  That is, if a person lives in two places, or more, there are rules as to who will b e the main taxing authority.  In this case it was a question as to whether Canada or the UK was the main taxing authority.  We all know that residency usually is the hallmark of where taxes are levied.  Mr. Black stated that he was a resident of two countries--Canada and the UK.  By the terms of the treaty he claimed that he was a domiciled non resident of the UK.  He claimed that, while he was willing to pay tax on income earned in Canada he was not willing to pay tax on his non resident income--some $5.1.  A tidy sum.  Canada claimed tax on the $5.1 million and the tax court agreed.  Notwithstanding the treaty that has tie breaking rules and notwithstanding that most observers believe that Mr. Black withstood the test of being a non resident of Canada, the tax court disagreed.  The tax court took a very liberal view of the tie breaking rules of the treaty.  I trust that Mr. Black will appeal and be successful in that appeal.

The arbitrariness of the CRA and now some of the courts indicates that any tax planning on an international level needs a further component:  asset protection.  While many business cannot benefit from asset protection (that is they have assets such as land, buildings, physical plants and accounts receivable in Canada that is open to seizure), many individuals and businesses who operate internationally have assets that are mainly in cash or cash equivalents.   Those individuals might be wise to secure these assets in jurisdictions where tax authorities would have difficulty in collecting on a tax judgement.  We have heard about some of these jurisdictions.  Cook Islands, Belize, Nevis, etc.  They are usually mentioned in a pejorative way.  However, since the object of business or individuals is keep their savings and wealth intact, the use of these jurisdictions is not only not pejorative but fiscally responsible.  That is practical tax planning.






Wednesday, 29 January 2014

The Current Plight of the CRA

My recent experience with the CRA has left me with a kind of Alice in Wonderland make believe world.  In truth the CRA is underfunded.  The recent cuts and more cuts of the Harper government has left the CRA labour short, labour untrained and labour unsupervised.  Recently a client received an assessment that was patently wrong.  Not a matter of conjecture or interpretation.  Just wrong.  A supervisor confirmed the assessment.  Again wrong.  The matter was taken to appeals in Shawinigan. The appeals officer threw the assessment out.  Why?  Because it was patently wrong.  The client had spent $30,000 in legal and accounting fees and there was no redress.

In a recent expose by the CBC  went on a hunt for tax cheats.  This included hidden cameras and gotcha interviews in Canada and Barbados.  No one from CRA was interviewed but it was implied, with a wink and a nod, that CRA was on top of this.  Most of the information was bogus.  But what it did was to falsely implicate literally thousands of legitimate companies that are formed in Barbados by Canadian parent companies.   Of course this made the CRA and the government of the day look bad.  What were all of these tax cheats doing running around Bridgetown.  While as a direct result of this reporting or otherwise the CRA has created a newly formed group that deals with international trading transaction.  A recent run in with one of that group has left me gaping in disbelief.  After hundreds of hours of both the CRA official's time and time of company personnel and after the transfer of thousands of pieces of documentation, the CRA has taken the position that the transactions between the Canadian company and the Barbados company is a sham!   CRA has taken the position that it will disregard binding contracts between the companies.  I could have understood discussions regarding transfer pricing (that is the price at which goods are sold from the Canadian company to its Barbados subsidiary) or even a discussion about whether "management mind and control" existed in the Barbados (the Canadian company has employees in Barbados). However, the CRA took the lazy and intellectually dishonest way out.  In fact, counsel believes that this position taken by CRA is the strongest position for the company/taxpayer.  I believe that CRA will lose in court.  Tens of thousands will be spent on professional fees.  I wonder where all those highly trained persons in international trade/tax are hiding.

International tax/trade is at the crux of the Canadian economy.  Canada has always been a trading country but that trade consisted largely of automobiles and resources.  In the current world no Canadian company of any size can exist without some aspect of international trade.  While this may consist mainly of north-south trade, trade worldwide is becoming the norm.  The Internet and etrade have had a huge effect on business.  If someone purchases intellectual property, where title to that property resides is a key factor in where income is earned.  If that income is earned in a low/no tax jurisdiction so much the better.

If CRA persists in its iron fisted approach to international tax/trade it will drive business offshore so that none of the profits will be repatriated to Canada.  Since Canada has a capital deficit that would be a shame.


I'm Back



After almost two years of being away I have decided to continue my blog.  While the content will be, mostly, professional stuff I will be commenting on world and other political economic and other matters.  I found that the blog was cathartic.  It was a way in letting off some emotional steam that tends to build up.  So, loo for entries.  Please give me some feedback.  In that way I know that I am writing to someone other than the ether.